How did Richard from Quebec City lose $175,000 with a single panicked phone call?
March 2020. COVID-19 hits Canada. In three weeks — from February 19 to March 23 — the TSX drops 37% (source: S&P/TSX, Yahoo Finance). Richard, 58, from Quebec City, watches his $250,000 RRSP melt down to $165,000. He panics and sells everything.
Six months later, the markets had fully recovered. By 2025, the same portfolio would be worth approximately $340,000. Richard, on the other hand, has $165,000 plus a few thousand in interest. Total cost of his panic decision: roughly $175,000.
His story isn't unique — it repeats itself with every market downturn and has for over a century. The reason: most people don't understand that markets operate in cycles, as natural as the four seasons.
Take the test now: our 7 Pillars Scan evaluates your financial health in 5 minutes, for free. Or book a 15-minute discovery call with an advisor — no pressure, no commitment.
Let's break down the four phases of the economic cycle with real numbers and Quebec-based examples.
What are the 4 phases of the economic cycle?
The economy isn't a straight line that always goes up. It breathes — it inhales (growth) and exhales (slowdown). This rhythm has been repeating predictably for over 200 years. Think of the four seasons in Quebec: nobody panics when the leaves fall in October because we know spring will come back.
Phase 1: Expansion — when everything's going well, how long does it last?
This is the growth phase: businesses hire, unemployment drops, wages rise, the stock market climbs. It's the longest phase — typically between 3 and 8 years in Canada. Recent examples: 2015–2019 (post-2008 crisis) and the 2021–mid-2022 rebound (post-pandemic).
Phase 2: The peak — how do you know the party's winding down?
The economy is running too hot. Inflation rises, housing prices surge, speculation increases. Interest rates go up to cool things off. Recent example: late 2022, with inflation at 6.8% and rates skyrocketing.
Phase 3: Recession — is it really the end of the world?
The economy contracts for at least two quarters. Unemployment rises, people cut their spending, the stock market drops. But here's the most important point: it's temporary. Always. Recessions in Canada last an average of 6 to 18 months (source: Bank of Canada). The 2020 COVID recession? Only 3 months — the shortest in history.
Phase 4: The trough — why is this the best time to invest?
The economy hits bottom and stabilizes. Rates drop, governments inject stimulus. This is — ironically — the best time to invest. When everyone is afraid, when the headlines scream "disaster," that's exactly when bargains are everywhere. It's like buying winter coats in March — on sale because nobody wants them, but winter will come back.
Then the cycle starts over again. For more than 150 years, the Canadian economy has never failed to return to growth after a recession. Every single time. Without exception.
What's the real picture of the markets from 2015 to 2025?
Here's what actually happened — GDP (the health of the economy) and the stock markets (TSX and S&P 500).
| Year | Canada Real GDP | TSX (approx. return) | S&P 500 (approx. return) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2015 | +0.7% | −11% | +1% |
| 2016 | +1.0% | +18% | +10% |
| 2017 | +3.0% | +6% | +19% |
| 2018 | +2.8% | −12% | −6% |
| 2019 | +1.9% | +19% | +29% |
| 2020 | −5.0% | +6% | +16% |
| 2021 | +5.3% | +22% | +27% |
| 2022 | +3.8% | −9% | −19% |
| 2023 | +1.5% | +8% | +24% |
| 2024 | +1.6% | +18% | +23% |
| 2025 | +1.7% | +5% | +8% |
(Sources: S&P/TSX, World Bank GDP)
What do these 10 years of data tell us?
Markets don't go up in a straight line. Over 11 years, the TSX had 3 negative years and 8 positive ones. The odds are in your favour if you stay invested.
The economy and the stock market don't move together. In 2020, GDP dropped by 5% (the worst contraction since World War II), but the TSX ended the year at +6% and the S&P 500 at +16%. Markets anticipate the future — they start climbing back up before the real economy recovers.
The mini-cycles are clearly visible: expansion 2016–2019, sharp shock in March 2020, rebound 2020–2021, correction in 2022, recovery 2023–2025. The long-term trend is clearly, undeniably, upward.
How much did panic really cost Richard?
Imagine $10,000 in a diversified portfolio (60% stocks, 40% bonds) in January 2015:
| Period | Portfolio Value | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| January 2015 | $10,000 | Initial investment |
| End of 2017 | $11,800 | Steady growth |
| End of 2019 | $12,800 | Excellent year |
| March 2020 | $10,500 | Richard panics and sells HERE |
| End of 2020 | $13,400 | Spectacular recovery (which Richard misses) |
| End of 2021 | $15,500 | Exceptional year (which Richard misses) |
| End of 2023 | $15,800 | Solid recovery |
| End of 2025 | $18,500 | Value if stayed invested |
Richard sold at $10,500 and has approximately $11,600 in 2025 (savings account at 2%). Had he stayed invested: $18,500. Difference: $6,900 on $10,000. On his actual $250,000 portfolio, that's over $170,000 lost. Enough to fund several years of retirement — gone in a single phone call.
Richard considered himself a cautious investor. In reality, he did exactly the worst possible strategy: buy high and sell low.
Why does missing the 10 best trading days cut your returns in half?
Studies show that emotional behaviour is, by far, the worst enemy of investors. Not recessions, not crashes — their own emotional reactions.
Over 20 years in the S&P 500 (source: S&P 500, Yahoo Finance):
- Stayed fully invested: annualized return of ~9.8%
- Missed the 10 best days: return drops to 5.6%
- Missed the 20 best days: 2.9%
- Missed the 30 best days: 0.8%
And guess when those famous "best days" happen? Right after the worst ones. The biggest rebounds occur in the days or weeks following the biggest drops. If you sell during the drop, you automatically miss the rebound. You suffer 100% of the decline and 0% of the recovery.
Does market timing work?
No. Nobody — not Warren Buffett, not the best analysts on Wall Street — can consistently predict when the market will go up or down. Decades of studies confirm this.
The solution: Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA). Investing a fixed amount at regular intervals — $500 per month, rain or shine. When the market is high, your $500 buys less. When it's low, it buys more. It smooths out your purchase price and eliminates the stress of trying to "pick the right time."
4 strategies to get through an economic cycle without losing your money
Strategy 1: Why is "doing nothing" often the best decision in the stock market?
Time in the market beats timing the market. Always. Over any 20-year period — including both World Wars, the Great Depression, the 2008 crash, and the 2020 pandemic — a diversified portfolio has always delivered a positive return. The key is time. Not timing.
Strategy 2: How does diversification protect your portfolio?
A well-built portfolio includes Canadian, American, and international stocks, bonds, and possibly real estate in fund form. When one category drops, another rises (or drops less). In 2022, tech stocks fell 30%, but Canadian energy stocks climbed 25%. Diversification doesn't protect against every downturn, but it significantly cushions the blows.
Strategy 3: Why should you rebalance your portfolio once or twice a year?
If your target is 60% stocks / 40% bonds and after a good year in the market you're at 70/30, rebalance: sell some of what performed well (expensive) and buy what moved less (on sale). It's the mechanism that forces you to "buy low and sell high" automatically and without emotion.
Strategy 4: Why should you see market drops as sales, not disasters?
When your favourite store puts up a "30% off" sign, you're happy. But when the stock market drops 30%, everyone panics. That's the opposite of logic. If you believe major companies will still exist in 10 years, a 30% drop is a sale on quality assets. It's the Boxing Day of investing.
To take advantage of sales, you need to have cash available. That's where your emergency fund comes in — it's what disciplined investors understand. A good advisor plays a crucial role in preventing you from making emotional mistakes that cost tens of thousands of dollars.
In summary: 7 takeaways about economic cycles
- The economy operates in 4 phases — expansion, peak, recession, trough — as predictable as the seasons
- Over 11 years, the TSX had 3 negative years and 8 positive ones — the long-term trend is clearly upward
- Richard lost $175,000 by selling in panic in March 2020 — if he had done nothing, he'd have $340,000 today
- Missing the 10 best trading days over 20 years cuts your return from 9.8% to 5.6%
- Market timing doesn't work — even the professionals can't pull it off
- The DCA method (investing a fixed amount regularly) is the most effective antidote to panic
- Stay invested, diversify, rebalance annually, and see downturns as buying opportunities
What's your next concrete step?
You now know that economic cycles are normal — and that panic is your worst financial enemy. There's only one thing missing: action.
Option 1: Take your 7 Pillars Scan (free, 5 min)
Evaluate your 7 pillars of financial health in 5 minutes. Personalized results, confidential, no commitment.
Option 2: Book a 15-minute discovery call
Talk to an advisor to check if your portfolio is structured to weather the storms and come out stronger. No panic, no pressure — just a clear and reassuring plan.
Book my 15-minute discovery call →
For a complete picture of your situation, check out our 7 financial pillars assessment or explore the 7 pillars of financial health in Quebec 2026.
FAQ — Frequently asked questions about economic cycles
Updated March 2026 — TSX 2025: ~+5%. S&P 500 2025: ~+8%. BoC policy rate: 2.75%.
1. What is an economic cycle and how long does it last? An economic cycle has 4 phases: expansion, peak, recession, and trough. The total length of a cycle ranges from 5 to 12 years in Canada. The expansion phase is the longest (3 to 8 years), while recessions last an average of 6 to 18 months. The shortest recession in history (COVID-19, 2020) lasted only 3 months.
2. Do markets always recover after a downturn? Yes, historically, without exception. Over any 20-year period in the history of North American markets — including the World Wars, the Great Depression, the 2008 crash, and the 2020 pandemic — a diversified portfolio has always delivered a positive return. The key is time, not timing.
3. How much can you lose by panic-selling during a downturn? Richard's example illustrates the real cost: a $250,000 portfolio sold at the bottom in March 2020 resulted in a loss of approximately $175,000 compared to an investor who stayed invested. Missing the 10 best trading days over 20 years cuts the annual return from 9.8% to 5.6% — nearly in half.
4. What is Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA)? It's investing a fixed amount at regular intervals — for example, $500 per month, rain or shine. When the market is high, you buy fewer shares. When it's low, you buy more. It smooths out your average purchase price and eliminates the stress of choosing "the right time." It's the most effective antidote to emotional decisions.
5. Does market timing work for investors? No. Decades of academic studies confirm that even professional fund managers can't consistently beat the market by trying to "time" their entries and exits. The best trading days happen right after the worst ones — if you sell during the drop, you automatically miss the rebound.
6. How can you tell which phase of the economic cycle we're in as of 2026? As of March 2026, Canada appears to be in a phase of moderate expansion: GDP is growing at ~1.7%, rates are declining (from 5.00% to 2.75%), and inflation is normalizing at ~2.3%. Stock markets are posting positive but modest returns. A financial advisor can help you position your portfolio accordingly.
7. Why does the stock market recover before the real economy does? Stock markets don't reflect the present — they anticipate the future. In March 2020, as soon as governments announced stimulus packages and vaccines appeared on the horizon, markets looked 12–18 months ahead and began recovering, well before the real economy bounced back.
8. What role does a financial advisor play during a crisis? A good advisor prevents you from making emotional decisions that cost tens of thousands of dollars. They keep your long-term strategy on track, rebalance your portfolio, and remind you that recessions are temporary. An advisor's value is measured above all in moments of panic.
9. Does diversification really protect against a crash? Yes, significantly. In 2022, tech stocks fell 30%, but Canadian energy stocks climbed 25%. A diversified portfolio (Canadian/American/international stocks + bonds) cushions the blows and reduces volatility. It's not total protection, but it's your permanent safety net.
10. How do I prepare my portfolio for the next recession? Four key actions: (1) stay invested — never sell in panic, (2) diversify across asset classes and geographic regions, (3) rebalance your portfolio 1 to 2 times a year, (4) maintain an emergency fund so you're never forced to sell your investments at the worst time. Our 7 Pillars Scan evaluates your readiness in 5 minutes.
11. What should you do during a recession in 2026 in Quebec? Don't sell in panic — stay invested or, better yet, buy at low prices using Dollar-Cost Averaging (DCA). History shows that markets always recover: over any 20-year period, a diversified portfolio has delivered a positive return, without exception. Take advantage of a recession to rebalance, pay down high-interest debt, and strengthen your emergency fund. Take the 7 Pillars Scan to identify your priorities.
This article is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute personalized financial, tax, or legal advice. The figures presented are illustrative examples based on historical data and reasonable return assumptions. Past returns do not guarantee future returns. Consult a licensed financial advisor for recommendations tailored to your personal situation.
Sources and methodology
Data verified as of March 2026. This article is updated annually.
Data sources: - S&P/TSX Composite — Historical return data - S&P 500 — Historical return data - Bank of Canada — Historical economic data - World Bank — Indicator NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG (Canada Real GDP)
Calculations: Historical stock index returns are drawn from public sources. The panic vs. patience scenarios use real market data. The model diversified portfolio (60% stocks / 40% bonds) is calculated from the weighted historical returns of the indices.
* The names and situations presented in this article are entirely fictional and used for illustrative purposes only. Any resemblance to real persons is purely coincidental.
Past returns are not indicative of future returns. The projections and numerical examples are presented for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute a guarantee of results.
The calculations and data compilations were produced by Lawrence Shaw and verified with the assistance of artificial intelligence tools using official sources.
This article is published for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute personalized financial advice. The information presented is general in nature and does not take into account your personal situation. Consult your financial security advisor for recommendations tailored to your situation.
© 2026 La Clinique Financière Inc. All rights reserved.